This Week's Letters
Vote yes on intermediate school project
Editor:
I am writing with regard to the school building referendums before us this fall. In particular, I would like to speak to the building of a new intermediate school. I speak as a long time resident and teacher here in town, as well as a member of the present building committee.
Growing up, I was in the first class to attend all three years at what was the Scarborough Junior High at the time, housing grades seven, eight and nine. My first full-time teaching position was at the “junior high.” My children later were students there when it became a combination middle and intermediate school. By that time, both an addition and several portables were present. I have taught in four other schools housing grades three through five here in town – Dunstan, Oak Hill Grammar, Bessey and Wentworth. As the town has grown, these buildings, one by one, became obsolete and the three through five grades took over all of the original junior high with the opening of the present middle school.
Schools have a life span of effectiveness. My great aunt was superintendent of schools here in town when the high school, later known as the Bessey School, was planned and built. At the time, she and the town fathers had the forethought to build a school to meet the needs of the student population of that time. In 1927, this was considered a huge undertaking, both physically as well as monetarily.
Today, I believe we are at a point, once again, where we as citizens need to support the building of a new intermediate school that will effectively meet the educational needs of our student population. I hope my junior high, my children’s middle school, the present Wentworth Intermediate School will not also be my future grandchildren’s intermediate school.
As a past, present and future taxpayer and conservative voter in town, I see this project, which will, yes, increase my taxes, to be a sound, well planned out building decision.
If you did not have the opportunity to see the Town Council’s public hearing when it aired Oct. 17, I hope you will be able to view a replay. An excellent explanation of the building projects was presented at this time. Many outstanding and valid points were expressed.
I hope you will support the Wentworth School project with a “yes” vote, as I plan to, on Nov. 7. As a teacher and taxpayer, I feel a vote for our schools this fall will have a positive impact on Scarborough as we approach our 350th anniversary.
Joyce Delaware Alden
Scarborough
Support school building proposals
Editor:
I would like to commend the respective Wentworth and Middle School Building Committees for their efforts during the past several months. As many residents know, there have been numerous school building committees through the years reviewing the challenges we face as a growing and desirable community. As far as I can determine, most of these committees have essentially recommended very similar solutions to our school capacity requirements.
The Wentworth Intermediate School is the last of the established facilities to be addressed in a comprehensive manner. Over the years the various committees have always considered Wentworth but more pressing needs at other facilities always seemed to trump Wentworth. Finally the needs and requirements of a deteriorating “intermediate” school are being address. This committee, as others in the past, has considered all the alternatives and its recommendation is the one being presented to the voters. As in the past, renovation was certainly an option to consider. I believe the general rule of thumb in the building community is that when a structure exceeds 60 percent of the cost of a replacement, then the replacement is the better option. If I’m not mistaken, renovating Wentworth now would represent close to 80% of the replacement cost. Sure, $38,322,803 is a lot of money, but it boils down to a cost to taxpayers of $3.19 per month (or $.74 per week) based on a average home valued at $289,800 (according to the assessor’s office) during its most expensive year, 2009. I would urge voters to support this proposal.
I had the privilege of chairing the original Middle School Building Committee. We knew from the very beginning that it would be near capacity as soon as the doors opened. This school was mostly paid for by the state. Nevertheless we had to have a town referendum to add just four classrooms to one wing and expand the café to accommodate the expected student population. This current expansion proposal doesn’t surprise me based on the town’s growth. Again, this building committee considered alternatives in conjunction with the intermediate school. There were discussions of rearranging the grade structure, moving the sixth grade to Wentworth and creating a grade three through six school. I believe there are still a few individuals who would prefer to see this arrangement, but the majority of those who have considered the alternatives prefer to retain the current grade structure. For those who may not be aware, the generally accepted grade structure in the entire country is that which we currently have – K-2, 3-5, 6-8 and high school – based on a school population such as ours. During the past 20 to 25 years, the importance of a true middle school philosophy emerged based on students in grades six through eight. Anyone who has experienced children during these years recognizes how many changes occur both physically and emotionally. Again, considering the most expensive year, 2009, the cost to taxpayers based on a home valued at $289,800 would be $2.72 per month ($.63 per week). I would urge voters to support of this proposal as well.
I would ask voters this question – by rejecting these proposals, do you really believe the problem of maintaining a deteriorating school (Wentworth) and overcrowding in both schools will disappear?
Roger Beeley
Scarborough
Maine can take a lesson from Proposition 2 1/2
Editor:
I would like to offer a little perspective to the controversy around TABOR. Many Mainers seem to have vociferous but uninformed opinions on this subject. But how many have bothered to look beyond the state line?
The TABOR approach has been tried in Massachusetts for several decades now. It is a disaster and Proposition 2 1/2 (as it is called there) is one of the reasons my husband and I recently relocated to Scarborough.
When towns are restricted by this sort of law, they must consult the taxpayers about every new expenditure. Let's face it – no one ever wants their taxes to go up. However, expenses can rise far beyond the inflation rate.
In our Massachusetts town (North Andover), the suddenly astronomical cost of health care for town employees, coupled with skyrocketing special education costs and a barely sufficient tax base, wreaked havoc with the school budget. Taxpayers, who had approved one override to build a new high school several years ago, repeatedly refused to fund any more overrides for the schools, shouting things like "I live within my budget – you live within yours!" at school committee meetings. Seniors organized themselves vigilantly to defeat any possible tax increase. Here's the result – in the last several years, over eighty school personnel have been laid off (the town has a population of 27,000), most class sizes are in the high thirties, parents must pay hundreds of dollars for any sport their child participates in as well as $300 per child for bus service, almost all “extras” (computer class, technology class, arts classes, music classes, foreign language prior to high school, all school librarians, any related arts, and many more) have been eliminated and the high school is slated to lose accreditation in 2007.
Is this what Maine wants?
Mary Burdick
Scarborough
The issue of a senior center ‘has been settled’
Editor:
I am writing in response to Mr. Billings letter (Leader, Oct. 13).
He states that seniors deserve a senior center. Why? He never really justifies it in his letter. Every senior I talked to was adamant about the fact that they, and the town of Scarborough, did not need a senior center. That is why they, and myself, voted against it.
As far as I am concerned, this issue has been settled. Why does he insist going against the voice of the people that voted on this issue? If he wants a senior center, start raising the money. There are grants, loans and other sources of money other than the town of Scarborough.
Jonathan Carr
Scarborough
Vote for Blais for county sheriff
Editor:
On Election Day, please cast your vote for Edward Blais, who is running for Cumberland County sheriff!
He has the experience – 20 years as a Gorham police officer and is currently the chief of police at the University of Maine at Farmington.
"Ted" will be tough on illegal drugs, unlike his opponent who at one time proposed to use confiscated marijuana for ill patients. He will better oversee our jails so that inmates with infectious diseases, like TB, will not be housed with the general population. Ted would also improve the working conditions and morale at the Portland jail so that workers wouldn't be forced to take so many overtime hours. He promises to be fiscally responsible, unlike the current sheriff who has almost doubled his budget in eight years.
Edward Blais is a hard working, positive, approachable, dedicated man who truly wants to be Cumberland County's new sheriff. On Nov. 7, please vote for Edward Blais for sheriff!
Jaymie Chamberlin
Scarborough
Peggy Pendleton is the right choice
Editor:
I have had the pleasure of getting to know Peggy Pendleton this year. The residents of Scarborough are so fortunate to have such a dedicated, smart, and down-to-earth individual running for House District 128.
Peggy Pendleton is all about priorities, people and policies. Her priorities are in the right place; she believes that government is to serve the interests of the people, not special interests. As a former State Senator and House Representative, she served her constituents well, left partisan politics behind and was a strong independent voice. As our future House Representative in District 128, she will again be an outstanding public servant.
As a long-time Mainer, Peggy knows and understands the people of Maine and cares deeply about her community and neighbors. Peggy’s experience as a nurse and nurse educator for more than 24 years will assist her in making complex policy decisions about health care and prescription drugs. Her tenure in Augusta has given her a strong grasp on other issues as well, including jobs, education, the environment, health care and taxes. She has the experience to promote sound policies to address these complex issues. She knows what is important to her constituents and how to serve as their voice in the legislature.
If you want your voice to be heard in Augusta, Peggy is your choice. Peggy is wonderful candidate and she deserves our support.
Beth George
Scarborough
Thank you, Good Samaritan
Editor:
On Columbus Day weekend, I dropped our cell phone on the ground while getting into the car at the Audubon's East Point Sanctuary at Biddeford Pool, but did not discover the loss until half an hour later when near Scarborough. When we arrived back at the sanctuary, the cell phone, to my relief, was attached to a branch of a hedgerow.
Thanks to the thoughtfulness of an unknown Good Samaritan, our weekend was not spoiled. My sister and brother-in-law, who live in Scarborough, said such behavior is almost universal amongst Maine residents. To the unknown Good Samaritan, thank you.
Tom Gilhooley
Camillus, N.Y.
Peggy Pendleton ‘will listen to all of us’
Editor:
We are writing this letter in support of Peggy Pendleton’s campaign for the Maine House District 128.
First, Peggy has the experience to do a great job for Scarborough residents. Peggy and her family have lived in Scarborough for 30 years. She, therefore, is keenly interested in and aware of the issues impacting all of Scarborough citizens and cares deeply about our community.
Second, Peggy has represented the town of Scarborough both in the Maine House for six years (1988-1994) and the Maine Senate for eight years (1996-2004). During this period of time she developed a thorough understanding of the legislative process and gained the respect and admiration of her peers from all sides of the political spectrum.
Peggy’s experience as a nurse educator for over 24 years will benefit our citizens in addressing the complicated health care issues that we continue to face. She is committed to improving our quality of life.
Peggy will bring an independent voice to Augusta because she has represented all of us and will listen to all of us. Therefore, we strongly urge you to vote for Peggy Pendleton on Nov. 7.
George and June Gillis
Scarborough
No respect of ‘senior intelligence’
Editor:
I agree with Councilor Jeff Messer – we voted you to office and some do talk out of both sides of your mouth.
I don’t need to mention any names, you know who sometimes come to senior functions, pitch in to help and act friendly.
You don’t respect senior intelligence – you want our vote.
Okay, if you don’t want to give us a senior center, work with us to get a community center with a designated senior wing near a kitchen and close by parking.
Barbara LaPrino
Scarborough
Are proposed school projects excessive?
Editor:
The citizens of Scarborough will be asked in the upcoming election to vote on $55 million in school infrastructure projects. It's difficult for the public to get a clear understanding of the size and scope of these projects. Let me take a moment to add some clarity to the issue.
The town debt in FY2002 was $35.1 million. The town debt in FY2005 was $67.8 million. This significant increase in debt (nearly double) was primarily because of the $26.8 million addition to the high school, which was the most expensive locally funded project in Maine history. We must carefully consider further adding to this debt.
The question before the voters is: Do the benefits of the project justify the costs or are the costs very excessive? There is no doubt the middle school, although relatively new, has a capacity issue and the intermediate school has outlived its useful life. However, Scarborough just recently funded the most costly local project in state history. Do we now ask our citizens to shatter this record by more than double the amount? We need to find a better answer. We need to be more realistic. Consider the following:
The current intermediate school (including modulars) is 105,000 square feet. The proposal on the ballot is to tear down the existing facility and construct a new building with 185,000 square feet. The proposal is to nearly double the size of the current facility even though capacity is not an issue.
A report presented to the State Board of Education by the Office of School Facilities indicates the national median is 125 square feet per student at these grade levels. The state requirement is 125 square feet per student. The figures provided by the architect are for 197 square feet per student, 58 percent higher than the national median and state requirement. Schools with comparable enrollment were recently built in Kennebunk, Lisbon and Old Town. These schools have between 125 and 135 square feet per student. Are we being excessive?
The report further indicates the national median for middle schools of similar size is 145 square feet per student. The state requirement is 135 square feet per student. The architect's figures are for 184 square feet per student. Middle schools with comparable enrollment were recently built in Waterboro, Biddeford, Kennebunk, Gorham, Oakland, Topsham and Cumberland. These schools have between 135 and 145 square feet per student. Are we being excessive again?
What is it that causes our needs to be so much greater than the rest of the country and the state? It would cost approximately $25 million less if these projects were built to the
national median or state requirements. Coming on the heels of the high school project, we must ensure these projects are built with a conscious blend of fiscal responsibility and realistic need. We must have a better balance.
It's very unfortunate the cost impact figures presented in the glossy brochures were so convoluted. The numbers presented clearly underestimate the tax impact. The format used makes it near impossible for the average citizen to understand the tax impact. Furthermore, the brochures list the average residential assessment as $290,000. According to the tax assessor, the average residential assessment is $372,000. You were given wrong information.
A simple calculation would be to borrow $55 million at five percent for 30 years. This yields an annual payment of $3.6 million. Adding this figure to the current budget results in a $1.07 increase in the tax rate, which is a tax increase of $400 for the average assessment in the first year. This figure will decline slightly year to year as the town continues to grow. The total cost for the average assessment would be $9,600 over the term of the bond.
I would suggest a no vote on these projects because the costs far exceed the realistic needs of our students and taxpayers. We need to continue to support quality education for our children. I would suggest setting a budget for about half of what is currently proposed to address this issue. We need to develop a more realistic request and then go to the citizens via referendum and ask for their support.
Jeffrey Messer
Scarborough Town Council
Pendleton is ‘compassionate and competent’
Editor:
I recently moved back to Scarborough after eight years in South Portland and, although I like South Portland very much, Scarborough just feels more like home to me. When I lived here before, I was a staunch supporter of Peggy Pendleton and I am delighted to see that she is running again for the legislature.
I know Peggy to be a very bright, compassionate and competent legislator and I am once again behind her 100 percent. I believe Maine has many outstanding lawmakers and Peggy Pendleton is at the top of my very short list.
Kendall Morse
Scarborough
Vote for Shawn Babine for house
Editor:
I am a Pine Point resident and senior in Scarborough and this Nov. 7, I'm voting for Councilor Shawn Babine for the Maine House.
I share Shawn's vision that is driven be a common cause for change. Shawn's energy, commitment to community and his vision represents what has been the successes of our past and where there is hope for our future.
During his six years of service to the School Board and Town Council, Shawn has been a conscientious listener to the people he serves, an advocate for the children and seniors of Scarborough, a fair and balanced legislator and a wonderful community leader.
Scarborough can be assured that in voting for Shawn for Maine House we will have a leader that represents all of Scarborough. With Shawn, we can be assured that at each legislative meeting he will enter the discussion in Augusta not as a Democrat, or as a Republican, but he will engage his colleagues as an independent voice for Scarborough. This is the type of leader we need in Augusta. As our state representative, Shawn will lend his experience as a corporate banker, a Scarborough leader and as a father, husband and caretaker to help move Maine forward. Join me this November and vote for Shawn for Maine House.
Judy Shirk
Scarborough
Remember the Animal Refuge League
Editor:
My husband and I were saddened earlier this week when, on the Black Point Road, we saw a kitten that had been hit by a car. After this experience, I thought I'd take a moment to remind my neighbors in Scarborough that there is a place to take kittens (and other abandoned or unwanted pets) where they have a chance for a loving, safe home – the Animal Refuge League on Stroudwater Road in Westbrook.
If you know of animals outside facing predators, traffic and/or the onset of a cold winter, please take them to the ARL where the wonderful staff will provide medical care, spay/neuter procedures and will work tirelessly to find a good home for each animal. Call them at 854-9771 or visit www.arlgp.org for more information. Your compassion saves animals – thank you!
Aubrey Strause
Scarborough
Thanks for making our yard sale a success
Editor:
Troop 39 of Scarborough wants to thank everyone for making our October Yard Sale a big success. Without you it wouldn’t have happened. We hope to see you at our roast beef supper at the Lions Club in December. Look for announcements soon.
Boy Scout Troop 39
Scarborough
Support Pendleton for house
Editor:
I had the honor of serving in the Maine Legislature with Peggy Pendleton in the past and was very happy to hear that she would be running for the Maine House of Representatives again.
As a recent report on the future of Maine and its economy has shown, we must re-examine how state and local government services are delivered. If we can streamline government and eliminate duplication of services we can save taxpayers money.
Peggy Pendleton has the experience Maine needs to move ahead with these efforts. She has served with great honesty and integrity as a past senate chairwoman of the legislature’s State and Local Government Committee.
Maine needs Peggy Pendleton’s leadership ability and experience in the house. I would urge voters in House District 128 (part of Scarborough) to vote for Peggy Pendleton.
Rep. John Tuttle
State Representative for District 143
Thanks for your support of Blake
Editor:
The family of Blake Vaillancourt would like to thank all of you who gave your support and worked so hard on the fundraisers and bone marrow drives to help Blake and our family.
We couldn’t have made it through without you. Your thoughtfulness and kindness throughout his illness will always be remembered. We deeply appreciate you all.
He passed away on August 18, 2006 at 8:32 p.m. in Seattle Children's Hospital with his family by his side. Though he will continue to be with us in spirit and in our hearts, Blake will be truly missed.
Anna Blake, Scott Bailey and Corinne Vaillancourt
Bangor
Editor:
I am writing with regard to the school building referendums before us this fall. In particular, I would like to speak to the building of a new intermediate school. I speak as a long time resident and teacher here in town, as well as a member of the present building committee.
Growing up, I was in the first class to attend all three years at what was the Scarborough Junior High at the time, housing grades seven, eight and nine. My first full-time teaching position was at the “junior high.” My children later were students there when it became a combination middle and intermediate school. By that time, both an addition and several portables were present. I have taught in four other schools housing grades three through five here in town – Dunstan, Oak Hill Grammar, Bessey and Wentworth. As the town has grown, these buildings, one by one, became obsolete and the three through five grades took over all of the original junior high with the opening of the present middle school.
Schools have a life span of effectiveness. My great aunt was superintendent of schools here in town when the high school, later known as the Bessey School, was planned and built. At the time, she and the town fathers had the forethought to build a school to meet the needs of the student population of that time. In 1927, this was considered a huge undertaking, both physically as well as monetarily.
Today, I believe we are at a point, once again, where we as citizens need to support the building of a new intermediate school that will effectively meet the educational needs of our student population. I hope my junior high, my children’s middle school, the present Wentworth Intermediate School will not also be my future grandchildren’s intermediate school.
As a past, present and future taxpayer and conservative voter in town, I see this project, which will, yes, increase my taxes, to be a sound, well planned out building decision.
If you did not have the opportunity to see the Town Council’s public hearing when it aired Oct. 17, I hope you will be able to view a replay. An excellent explanation of the building projects was presented at this time. Many outstanding and valid points were expressed.
I hope you will support the Wentworth School project with a “yes” vote, as I plan to, on Nov. 7. As a teacher and taxpayer, I feel a vote for our schools this fall will have a positive impact on Scarborough as we approach our 350th anniversary.
Joyce Delaware Alden
Scarborough
Support school building proposals
Editor:
I would like to commend the respective Wentworth and Middle School Building Committees for their efforts during the past several months. As many residents know, there have been numerous school building committees through the years reviewing the challenges we face as a growing and desirable community. As far as I can determine, most of these committees have essentially recommended very similar solutions to our school capacity requirements.
The Wentworth Intermediate School is the last of the established facilities to be addressed in a comprehensive manner. Over the years the various committees have always considered Wentworth but more pressing needs at other facilities always seemed to trump Wentworth. Finally the needs and requirements of a deteriorating “intermediate” school are being address. This committee, as others in the past, has considered all the alternatives and its recommendation is the one being presented to the voters. As in the past, renovation was certainly an option to consider. I believe the general rule of thumb in the building community is that when a structure exceeds 60 percent of the cost of a replacement, then the replacement is the better option. If I’m not mistaken, renovating Wentworth now would represent close to 80% of the replacement cost. Sure, $38,322,803 is a lot of money, but it boils down to a cost to taxpayers of $3.19 per month (or $.74 per week) based on a average home valued at $289,800 (according to the assessor’s office) during its most expensive year, 2009. I would urge voters to support this proposal.
I had the privilege of chairing the original Middle School Building Committee. We knew from the very beginning that it would be near capacity as soon as the doors opened. This school was mostly paid for by the state. Nevertheless we had to have a town referendum to add just four classrooms to one wing and expand the café to accommodate the expected student population. This current expansion proposal doesn’t surprise me based on the town’s growth. Again, this building committee considered alternatives in conjunction with the intermediate school. There were discussions of rearranging the grade structure, moving the sixth grade to Wentworth and creating a grade three through six school. I believe there are still a few individuals who would prefer to see this arrangement, but the majority of those who have considered the alternatives prefer to retain the current grade structure. For those who may not be aware, the generally accepted grade structure in the entire country is that which we currently have – K-2, 3-5, 6-8 and high school – based on a school population such as ours. During the past 20 to 25 years, the importance of a true middle school philosophy emerged based on students in grades six through eight. Anyone who has experienced children during these years recognizes how many changes occur both physically and emotionally. Again, considering the most expensive year, 2009, the cost to taxpayers based on a home valued at $289,800 would be $2.72 per month ($.63 per week). I would urge voters to support of this proposal as well.
I would ask voters this question – by rejecting these proposals, do you really believe the problem of maintaining a deteriorating school (Wentworth) and overcrowding in both schools will disappear?
Roger Beeley
Scarborough
Maine can take a lesson from Proposition 2 1/2
Editor:
I would like to offer a little perspective to the controversy around TABOR. Many Mainers seem to have vociferous but uninformed opinions on this subject. But how many have bothered to look beyond the state line?
The TABOR approach has been tried in Massachusetts for several decades now. It is a disaster and Proposition 2 1/2 (as it is called there) is one of the reasons my husband and I recently relocated to Scarborough.
When towns are restricted by this sort of law, they must consult the taxpayers about every new expenditure. Let's face it – no one ever wants their taxes to go up. However, expenses can rise far beyond the inflation rate.
In our Massachusetts town (North Andover), the suddenly astronomical cost of health care for town employees, coupled with skyrocketing special education costs and a barely sufficient tax base, wreaked havoc with the school budget. Taxpayers, who had approved one override to build a new high school several years ago, repeatedly refused to fund any more overrides for the schools, shouting things like "I live within my budget – you live within yours!" at school committee meetings. Seniors organized themselves vigilantly to defeat any possible tax increase. Here's the result – in the last several years, over eighty school personnel have been laid off (the town has a population of 27,000), most class sizes are in the high thirties, parents must pay hundreds of dollars for any sport their child participates in as well as $300 per child for bus service, almost all “extras” (computer class, technology class, arts classes, music classes, foreign language prior to high school, all school librarians, any related arts, and many more) have been eliminated and the high school is slated to lose accreditation in 2007.
Is this what Maine wants?
Mary Burdick
Scarborough
The issue of a senior center ‘has been settled’
Editor:
I am writing in response to Mr. Billings letter (Leader, Oct. 13).
He states that seniors deserve a senior center. Why? He never really justifies it in his letter. Every senior I talked to was adamant about the fact that they, and the town of Scarborough, did not need a senior center. That is why they, and myself, voted against it.
As far as I am concerned, this issue has been settled. Why does he insist going against the voice of the people that voted on this issue? If he wants a senior center, start raising the money. There are grants, loans and other sources of money other than the town of Scarborough.
Jonathan Carr
Scarborough
Vote for Blais for county sheriff
Editor:
On Election Day, please cast your vote for Edward Blais, who is running for Cumberland County sheriff!
He has the experience – 20 years as a Gorham police officer and is currently the chief of police at the University of Maine at Farmington.
"Ted" will be tough on illegal drugs, unlike his opponent who at one time proposed to use confiscated marijuana for ill patients. He will better oversee our jails so that inmates with infectious diseases, like TB, will not be housed with the general population. Ted would also improve the working conditions and morale at the Portland jail so that workers wouldn't be forced to take so many overtime hours. He promises to be fiscally responsible, unlike the current sheriff who has almost doubled his budget in eight years.
Edward Blais is a hard working, positive, approachable, dedicated man who truly wants to be Cumberland County's new sheriff. On Nov. 7, please vote for Edward Blais for sheriff!
Jaymie Chamberlin
Scarborough
Peggy Pendleton is the right choice
Editor:
I have had the pleasure of getting to know Peggy Pendleton this year. The residents of Scarborough are so fortunate to have such a dedicated, smart, and down-to-earth individual running for House District 128.
Peggy Pendleton is all about priorities, people and policies. Her priorities are in the right place; she believes that government is to serve the interests of the people, not special interests. As a former State Senator and House Representative, she served her constituents well, left partisan politics behind and was a strong independent voice. As our future House Representative in District 128, she will again be an outstanding public servant.
As a long-time Mainer, Peggy knows and understands the people of Maine and cares deeply about her community and neighbors. Peggy’s experience as a nurse and nurse educator for more than 24 years will assist her in making complex policy decisions about health care and prescription drugs. Her tenure in Augusta has given her a strong grasp on other issues as well, including jobs, education, the environment, health care and taxes. She has the experience to promote sound policies to address these complex issues. She knows what is important to her constituents and how to serve as their voice in the legislature.
If you want your voice to be heard in Augusta, Peggy is your choice. Peggy is wonderful candidate and she deserves our support.
Beth George
Scarborough
Thank you, Good Samaritan
Editor:
On Columbus Day weekend, I dropped our cell phone on the ground while getting into the car at the Audubon's East Point Sanctuary at Biddeford Pool, but did not discover the loss until half an hour later when near Scarborough. When we arrived back at the sanctuary, the cell phone, to my relief, was attached to a branch of a hedgerow.
Thanks to the thoughtfulness of an unknown Good Samaritan, our weekend was not spoiled. My sister and brother-in-law, who live in Scarborough, said such behavior is almost universal amongst Maine residents. To the unknown Good Samaritan, thank you.
Tom Gilhooley
Camillus, N.Y.
Peggy Pendleton ‘will listen to all of us’
Editor:
We are writing this letter in support of Peggy Pendleton’s campaign for the Maine House District 128.
First, Peggy has the experience to do a great job for Scarborough residents. Peggy and her family have lived in Scarborough for 30 years. She, therefore, is keenly interested in and aware of the issues impacting all of Scarborough citizens and cares deeply about our community.
Second, Peggy has represented the town of Scarborough both in the Maine House for six years (1988-1994) and the Maine Senate for eight years (1996-2004). During this period of time she developed a thorough understanding of the legislative process and gained the respect and admiration of her peers from all sides of the political spectrum.
Peggy’s experience as a nurse educator for over 24 years will benefit our citizens in addressing the complicated health care issues that we continue to face. She is committed to improving our quality of life.
Peggy will bring an independent voice to Augusta because she has represented all of us and will listen to all of us. Therefore, we strongly urge you to vote for Peggy Pendleton on Nov. 7.
George and June Gillis
Scarborough
No respect of ‘senior intelligence’
Editor:
I agree with Councilor Jeff Messer – we voted you to office and some do talk out of both sides of your mouth.
I don’t need to mention any names, you know who sometimes come to senior functions, pitch in to help and act friendly.
You don’t respect senior intelligence – you want our vote.
Okay, if you don’t want to give us a senior center, work with us to get a community center with a designated senior wing near a kitchen and close by parking.
Barbara LaPrino
Scarborough
Are proposed school projects excessive?
Editor:
The citizens of Scarborough will be asked in the upcoming election to vote on $55 million in school infrastructure projects. It's difficult for the public to get a clear understanding of the size and scope of these projects. Let me take a moment to add some clarity to the issue.
The town debt in FY2002 was $35.1 million. The town debt in FY2005 was $67.8 million. This significant increase in debt (nearly double) was primarily because of the $26.8 million addition to the high school, which was the most expensive locally funded project in Maine history. We must carefully consider further adding to this debt.
The question before the voters is: Do the benefits of the project justify the costs or are the costs very excessive? There is no doubt the middle school, although relatively new, has a capacity issue and the intermediate school has outlived its useful life. However, Scarborough just recently funded the most costly local project in state history. Do we now ask our citizens to shatter this record by more than double the amount? We need to find a better answer. We need to be more realistic. Consider the following:
The current intermediate school (including modulars) is 105,000 square feet. The proposal on the ballot is to tear down the existing facility and construct a new building with 185,000 square feet. The proposal is to nearly double the size of the current facility even though capacity is not an issue.
A report presented to the State Board of Education by the Office of School Facilities indicates the national median is 125 square feet per student at these grade levels. The state requirement is 125 square feet per student. The figures provided by the architect are for 197 square feet per student, 58 percent higher than the national median and state requirement. Schools with comparable enrollment were recently built in Kennebunk, Lisbon and Old Town. These schools have between 125 and 135 square feet per student. Are we being excessive?
The report further indicates the national median for middle schools of similar size is 145 square feet per student. The state requirement is 135 square feet per student. The architect's figures are for 184 square feet per student. Middle schools with comparable enrollment were recently built in Waterboro, Biddeford, Kennebunk, Gorham, Oakland, Topsham and Cumberland. These schools have between 135 and 145 square feet per student. Are we being excessive again?
What is it that causes our needs to be so much greater than the rest of the country and the state? It would cost approximately $25 million less if these projects were built to the
national median or state requirements. Coming on the heels of the high school project, we must ensure these projects are built with a conscious blend of fiscal responsibility and realistic need. We must have a better balance.
It's very unfortunate the cost impact figures presented in the glossy brochures were so convoluted. The numbers presented clearly underestimate the tax impact. The format used makes it near impossible for the average citizen to understand the tax impact. Furthermore, the brochures list the average residential assessment as $290,000. According to the tax assessor, the average residential assessment is $372,000. You were given wrong information.
A simple calculation would be to borrow $55 million at five percent for 30 years. This yields an annual payment of $3.6 million. Adding this figure to the current budget results in a $1.07 increase in the tax rate, which is a tax increase of $400 for the average assessment in the first year. This figure will decline slightly year to year as the town continues to grow. The total cost for the average assessment would be $9,600 over the term of the bond.
I would suggest a no vote on these projects because the costs far exceed the realistic needs of our students and taxpayers. We need to continue to support quality education for our children. I would suggest setting a budget for about half of what is currently proposed to address this issue. We need to develop a more realistic request and then go to the citizens via referendum and ask for their support.
Jeffrey Messer
Scarborough Town Council
Pendleton is ‘compassionate and competent’
Editor:
I recently moved back to Scarborough after eight years in South Portland and, although I like South Portland very much, Scarborough just feels more like home to me. When I lived here before, I was a staunch supporter of Peggy Pendleton and I am delighted to see that she is running again for the legislature.
I know Peggy to be a very bright, compassionate and competent legislator and I am once again behind her 100 percent. I believe Maine has many outstanding lawmakers and Peggy Pendleton is at the top of my very short list.
Kendall Morse
Scarborough
Vote for Shawn Babine for house
Editor:
I am a Pine Point resident and senior in Scarborough and this Nov. 7, I'm voting for Councilor Shawn Babine for the Maine House.
I share Shawn's vision that is driven be a common cause for change. Shawn's energy, commitment to community and his vision represents what has been the successes of our past and where there is hope for our future.
During his six years of service to the School Board and Town Council, Shawn has been a conscientious listener to the people he serves, an advocate for the children and seniors of Scarborough, a fair and balanced legislator and a wonderful community leader.
Scarborough can be assured that in voting for Shawn for Maine House we will have a leader that represents all of Scarborough. With Shawn, we can be assured that at each legislative meeting he will enter the discussion in Augusta not as a Democrat, or as a Republican, but he will engage his colleagues as an independent voice for Scarborough. This is the type of leader we need in Augusta. As our state representative, Shawn will lend his experience as a corporate banker, a Scarborough leader and as a father, husband and caretaker to help move Maine forward. Join me this November and vote for Shawn for Maine House.
Judy Shirk
Scarborough
Remember the Animal Refuge League
Editor:
My husband and I were saddened earlier this week when, on the Black Point Road, we saw a kitten that had been hit by a car. After this experience, I thought I'd take a moment to remind my neighbors in Scarborough that there is a place to take kittens (and other abandoned or unwanted pets) where they have a chance for a loving, safe home – the Animal Refuge League on Stroudwater Road in Westbrook.
If you know of animals outside facing predators, traffic and/or the onset of a cold winter, please take them to the ARL where the wonderful staff will provide medical care, spay/neuter procedures and will work tirelessly to find a good home for each animal. Call them at 854-9771 or visit www.arlgp.org for more information. Your compassion saves animals – thank you!
Aubrey Strause
Scarborough
Thanks for making our yard sale a success
Editor:
Troop 39 of Scarborough wants to thank everyone for making our October Yard Sale a big success. Without you it wouldn’t have happened. We hope to see you at our roast beef supper at the Lions Club in December. Look for announcements soon.
Boy Scout Troop 39
Scarborough
Support Pendleton for house
Editor:
I had the honor of serving in the Maine Legislature with Peggy Pendleton in the past and was very happy to hear that she would be running for the Maine House of Representatives again.
As a recent report on the future of Maine and its economy has shown, we must re-examine how state and local government services are delivered. If we can streamline government and eliminate duplication of services we can save taxpayers money.
Peggy Pendleton has the experience Maine needs to move ahead with these efforts. She has served with great honesty and integrity as a past senate chairwoman of the legislature’s State and Local Government Committee.
Maine needs Peggy Pendleton’s leadership ability and experience in the house. I would urge voters in House District 128 (part of Scarborough) to vote for Peggy Pendleton.
Rep. John Tuttle
State Representative for District 143
Thanks for your support of Blake
Editor:
The family of Blake Vaillancourt would like to thank all of you who gave your support and worked so hard on the fundraisers and bone marrow drives to help Blake and our family.
We couldn’t have made it through without you. Your thoughtfulness and kindness throughout his illness will always be remembered. We deeply appreciate you all.
He passed away on August 18, 2006 at 8:32 p.m. in Seattle Children's Hospital with his family by his side. Though he will continue to be with us in spirit and in our hearts, Blake will be truly missed.
Anna Blake, Scott Bailey and Corinne Vaillancourt
Bangor
Comments